Tenant And Landlord Liability To Visitors For Injuries On Leased Premises

DISCLAIMER: The following is provided for referencecases.
purposes only and not as legal advice.Negligence is when you are not aware of the risk but
Dear reader, you are lucky. If I had been writing on thisshould have been - you failed to check your home for
topic not all that long ago I would have needed a smallnecessary repairs, for example, and someone falls
textbook to even begin an introduction to its arcanethrough a rotten stairwell. Recklessness is when you
complexities. But the modern trend has been toknew of the risk but ignored it - for example, you
simplify it all into a reasonable set of rules andknew the stairs were rotten but delayed fixing them
principles that are - well, common sense based.and then invited your mother-in-law over. Willfulness is
Put simply, the tenant has a much greater overallwhen you intentionally expose someone to an
liability for injuries to visitors occurring on propertyunreasonable risk ("Let's put banana peels all over the
owned by the landlord but rented by the tenant. Suchbasement stairs and film Linda when she falls - she's
injuries can take many forms:so CUTE when she's angry!") Note that in order for
(1) The postman is bitten by the family dog and comesthe offending conduct to be willful, you don't have to
down with rabies.intend that anyone get injured - you just have to intend
(2) A child chasing a runaway ball wanders onto thethat they be exposed to an unreasonable risk of injury.
rented property and falls into a ditch, breaking his leg.The foregoing reveals why tenants are generally more
(3) A guest suffers an electric shock turning on a lampat risk than landlords - because they possess the
due to defective wiring in a private home.property, they have more control over its condition
(4) A guest suffers smoke inhalation due to a fire in anthan the landlord does and thus have more duties that
office building that was caused by defective wiring.can possibly be breached to result in an injury. The
The general standard used in most jurisdiction is thelandlord's responsibility is at its greatest when he has a
same "negligence, recklessness, and willfulness"duty to keep certain aspect of the premises in good
standard that is used in most personal injury cases.repair - for example, the landlord is usually responsible
The liability gets greater as you go up the scale fromfor complying with the fire code.
negligence to willfulness, including criminal liability in some